Alabama Supreme Court Justice Champ Lions who was part of the group that opposed and persecuted Chief Justice Roy Moore has written a paper in which he argues that the oath of office directs the judge to swear allegiance to men. Matt Chancey offers a brilliant refutation at the visionforum.org web site. The article is called “Constitutions, Oaths, and the Heritage of English Law: A response to Justice Champ Lyons, Jr.”